Archive: “More T-Junctions, Vicar?”

DTW presents another look back at the archives of motoring writer Archie Vicar. This item appears to be a transcript from “Motorists and Motorism”, August 1975.

1975 Simca 1301: best car of Vicar´s week.
1975 Simca 1301: best car of Vicar’s week.

What a week and indeed what a summer it has been so far. In May I had a chance to sample Michelin’s tyres at a special “closed track” day at Silverstone. A Mercedes 240D and a Peugeot 504 LD served as test-beds for Michelin’s new all-weather radial tyres. Peugeot have thought to bring these diesel cars over as they have had enough experience selling them on the continent. Also, seems as if they don’t want to lose ground to Mercedes.

Both cars are on an equal footing – astonishingly quiet for derv burners. Of course, the Peugeot is the finer car to drive and the Mercedes is the one Jones will admire you for. Both cars hated the track and under-steered woefully. I gave up after twenty minutes and had a good chat about whiskey with a representative from Laphroaig who happened to be there. For laughs we took his Cortina 1600 out onto the track and the Pirelli Cinturatos CF67 he had fitted really made a noticeable difference. Much better than the Michelins.

1975 Renault 5. Image:
1975 Renault 5. Image:

All of that got me thinking about tyres again. So with the help of the nice men and women at Fiat, Renault and VW, last week I ordered up some rubber from Avon, Michelin and Goodyear to fit to the 127DL, 5TL and Polo N on the Motorists and Motorism long-term fleet. The tyres were compounded for general purpose, summer and winter; none of them made the slightest difference.

All these cars are painfully slow. The Polo is smooth but this hides a lack of response. The Renault sounds quite sporty yet covers ground as slowly as the Polo. And the Fiat wouldn’t start, at first. With any of the nine tyres, and at various pressures, the Fiat behaved the same: it understeered woefully and stalled.

Simca invited we gentlemen of the press to test their revised 1301 saloon. Seat belts are standard fittings and the carpet, which extends from door to door, seemed quite well fitted. I remember that because I dropped my pipe. We had a very fine lunch at the Bottle and Glass Inn in Dudley. They had excellent black pudding and Dudley’s best pork pie (making it Britain’s best pork pie). The Simca’s odd – it looks like a cross between a Mercedes and a Hillman. I am sure it will sell.

Bottle and Glass Inn, Dudley.
Bottle and Glass Inn, Dudley.

Still in the Midlands, and down to Brown’s Lane, Coventry, where we tested the XJ 3.4. Still two fuel tanks. Oddly, the lunch was again at the Bottle and Glass Inn where we had the same black pudding and pork pie. The power steering of the XJ is nice and light, I can report. All in all the smaller-engined car is not fast enough to show up the wobbles that the 4.2 litre car does. I asked about how various tyre compounds affected the ride and the man from Jaguar said the car was optimised for all tyres. The front seats are awful but the cloth is nice. Why people ask for leather is beyond me. I hope a 2.5 litre version comes out at some time.

Finally, BMW’s British office showed off their 320 two-door. If you had to point out one of the few good points about these otherwise tinny little cars, the worm and roller steering was the thing you’d mention. Dropped now. It’s rack and pinion. The brakes are still discs and drums but they are ventilated on posher models. The model range looks much like the old model range though.

Alas, the sporty character – what little there was – has been diluted. The 320 lopes rather. Fine for Renault and Rover but not for a car claiming to be for the press-on driver. The damping is terrible. Hopefully Triumph can maintain their advantage – new car’s due for 1980 a bird tells me. I drove the BMW across the Midlands which led me back to the Bottle and Glass Inn: that pork pie more than made up for the failings of the Bavarian box.

So, a week of tyres and pork pies. Best car: the Simca.

For more of Archie Vicar’s period car reviews, click here

Author: richard herriott

I like anchovies. I dislike post-war town planning.

7 thoughts on “Archive: “More T-Junctions, Vicar?””

  1. The original Simca 1300 was neat and well proportioned, but the Mercedes like rear facelift (rearlift?) gave it a bigger boot, but looked like it came from a different car.

  2. That´s what I thought. I find the lamps and grille disappointing.These are pretty forgotten cars, aren´t they? I suppose in the middle 70s they must have been part of the French street scene.
    Even when I was growing up and becoming aware of cars, Simca was a rarity.

  3. That boot doesn’t bother me too much. What I remember the most from Simcas in my childhood was the very crude sounding engines. The noise they made was even worse than Fords of that time.

    My grandmother had a Simca 1000 that she drove from the mid 1960’s to the early 90’s

  4. “I asked about how various tyre compounds affected the ride and the man from Jaguar said the car was optimised for all tyres.” This is the sort of engineering acumen that’s been sorely missing from our American manufacturers since the demise of AMC, at least. Indeed, why prioritize one thing, when one can prioritize everything across the board? Here’s to the “Old” Jaguar. We miss you, almost as much as that French tart Renault.

  5. Hi Phil! Have you wandered across from TTAC?
    Welcome and feel free to join in the general chatter here.
    In marked contrast Lancia tuned the Trevi suspension around one tyre, Pirelli P-6000s (I think). Presumably there’s a risk of leaving the car vulnerable to unwanted consequences if a later owner fits another type of tyre.

  6. Thanks, RH. Came here while drifting around, thinking about a particular old Simca. Now it’s a permanent bookmark. Great stuff. Yes, the consequences of too specific tuning – especially on national lines – can be dire. I once tried to fit Yokohamas to my 1750 GTV. She wouldn’t start, and pouted in my garage until I brought her fresh Cinturatos. She’s… with an aerospace engineer on the other side of town, now. Best regards from Austin, Texas.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: