Wholly Toledo: A Two Part Look At SEAT’s Ragbag Nameplate

With apologies to anyone who expected something else when Googling the term “Wholly Toledo”. I just wanted an amusing play on words so I could make this fake magazine cover:

If it doesn't exist, I will invent it. Wholly Toledo is the popular magazine for UK fans of the SEAT Toledo.
If it doesn’t exist, I will invent it. Wholly Toledo is the popular magazine for UK fans of the SEAT Toledo.

The Seat Toledo. How often does this name come up? Answer: not very much. Yet since 1991, SEAT have been selling something tagged as such. Right now it’s a quite conservatively styled medium-small car with the neat conceit of looking like a saloon but actually being a hatchback. Haven’t we heard this before?

Regular readers here will know what prompted this line of inquiry, the recent launch of Fiat’s Æegea which in turn led me to ask if anyone could remember a small Daihatsu saloon. The answer was the Applause which was a small five door car that looked like a saloon. What do you know but the concept is alive and well. I had a closer look at a Toledo and noticed that it has a rather neatly disguised fifth door. Apart from the second generation (1998-2002), all of them have been hatches but even then, these cars have been very different from one another. Let’s take a short look back.

1992 Seat Toledo. Made in Spain: www.bestsellingcarsblog.com
1992 Seat Toledo. Made in Spain: http://www.bestsellingcarsblog.com

ItalDesign styled the first Toledo which VAG’s engineers based on the Mk 2 Golf. Looking for a USP to distance it from the Jetta, SEAT made the Toledo a hatchback though it did not look like one. ItalDesign seemed to have a hard time with the styling as it really doesn’t look like very much. There wasn’t much to go on, of course, but ItalDesign didn’t go out of their way to give the vehicle much identity: bland, about sums it up. But spacious and blessed with a big boot. The engines ranged from 1.6 to 2.0 via 1.8; a diesel could be had as well. Was it popular? No, not very, though Car magazine liked it for its blend of good value and easy performance.

This one is for sale in Cork, Ireland. It´s a 2000 diesel: cars-mitula.ie
This one is for sale in Cork, Ireland. It´s a 2000 diesel: cars-mitula.ie

For the second generation, ItalDesign tried to give the car a more corporate VW look. In fact, the design is so immaculately neat one wonders how much of an input ItalDesign really had. It shared major components with the VW Bora and Skoda Octavia; allegedly the Toledo had a sporting role in this incarnation since SEAT had been charged with going after Alfa Romeo or at least being a Spanish sporty car. Really, all three cars are about as sporty as one another, which is either a bit sporty by dint of their handy size or not very sporty at all.

The car did however have VW five-cylinder 2.3 litre engine to give it some credibility and for that we must give it a little respect. Sales remained a bit slow. The boot size on this version lost 50 litres compared to the Mark 1 and the dashboard borrowed bits from the Audi A3.

While we're on the subject of second hand, it's your chance to contact Drimnagh Motors for a 2005 diesel Toledo. Drimnagh Motors, Drimnagh's best used-car dealer for SEATs: www.carsireland.ie
While we’re on the subject of second hand, it’s your chance to contact Drimnagh Motors for a 2005 diesel Toledo. Drimnagh Motors, Drimnagh’s best used-car dealer for SEATs: http://www.carsireland.ie

With Walter da Silva poached from Alfa Romeo (1999), the natural thing to do was not perhaps to throw out all the athletic pretensions of the Mk2 yet this is what they did. The 2005-2009 Toledo got on the bandwagon that started rolling with the Renault Vel Satis (2002) and crashed with it. It depends on how you look at this matter: brave or stupid? The Vel Satis has a distinctive and huge rear screen which moves in one piece, while the Toledo has a pretty standard hatchback and a reverse-rake c-pillar in the style of the Mercedes A-class, Toyota Picnic and later Peugeot 407 SW. The real point is that the Toledo now looked like a hatchback and was a hatchback. The five cylinder engine vanished from the line-up. The boot volume stayed the same despite the upright shape and generally puffed-up appearance. There was little substance to the style and the performance aspect evaporated.

In 2009 production of the Toledo ended and VAG took a while to think of what else to do with the name.

More to follow….

Author: richard herriott

I like anchovies. I dislike post-war town planning.

4 thoughts on “Wholly Toledo: A Two Part Look At SEAT’s Ragbag Nameplate”

  1. I’m actually pretty fond of what Walter de’Silva did at Seat. His Leon is a better, calmer yet more distinctive effort than its successor.
    That being said, I never understood the Toledo. What was its point really – given there were the similarly sized minivans Altea and Altea XL? Quite an odd now-we-become-Alfa-triumvirate.

    What VW did with the name: Sell a Skoda Rapid.

  2. It’s nice to see the publishers of Car Chat(Still only 99p!) – branching out. Apparently Wholly Toledo is just the first of many one-make magazines they have planned. Ford fans will be thrilled to learn that shortly they can purchase Hocus Focus, focusing on the common myths and orthodoxies that have built up around Ford’s bestseller. It’s bitter rival, Astranomics will offer running and money saving tips for Vauxhall fans across the length and breadth of the nation. Civic Minded aims to do likewise for Honda owners.

    “We haven’t even started yet”, Car Chat publisher-In-Chief, Geoff Climax told us yesterday.”Just wait until we launch Jazz Mag! It’ll blow your mind!”

  3. Thanks, Eoin but I hope I don´t have to spell out the fact that Wholly Toledo is in a different class from Car Chat, thanks. It´s a quality mag with proper photos by professional Toledo enthusiasts. There is one fly in the ointment, and that is an ongoing legal tussle with Holy Toledo, the specialist magazing for Triumph Toledo owners.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: