And Here Are the Results of the Irish Jury.

Reading the tea leaves from Ireland’s 2016 car sales figures.

Image: adworld-ie
Image: adworld-ie

As some of you might have gathered by now, I find motor statistics quite absorbing. Okay, it’s often a little like tea leaf prophecy, but car sales figures can be revealing. However, since full-year European data is still pending, we’ll have to contain ourselves and make do with the Society of the Irish Motor Industry who’ve released statistics for January-December 2016. The Republic of Ireland market is small, but even so, 146, 672 new car sales is not to be sneezed at, especially as it shows a rise of 17.5% over that of the previous year.

The 2016 top ten looks a little like this (note: the percentage figure represents the net gain over 2015 figures).

Toyota     15,523 +18%
Hyundai  15,442 +35%
VW           15,408 +0.3%
Ford         14,595 +21%
Nissan      11,885 +6%
Škoda        9,447 +21%
Renault     8,379 +38%
Opel           7,887 +5%
Kia             6,710 +22%
Audi           6,065 +16%

What we see here are the top three virtually neck and neck in volume terms. More interesting though are the percentage gains and the likely rationale behind them. Both Toyota and (particularly) Hyundai for instance have been offering quite aggressive sales incentives – both seemingly hell bent on breaking VW’s market dominance. It is probably this pincer movement, as much as any latter fallout from NOxgate that has seen VW’s market share fall, despite showing (very) modest gains for the year as a whole. Škoda has done significantly better with a 21% sales rise on the back of a now very complete car range. Their current advertising campaign also makes an astute connection with Irish motorists, further embedding the brand in local hearts and minds without a big name brand ambassador in sight.

Renault too appears to be on a roll, with Clios and Capturs seemingly flying off forecourts if ocular evidence is any barometer. With a sales hike of 38%, the incentives are also believed to be flying. PSA would probably kill for numbers like this, but perhaps Mr Tavares is playing a longer game.
Once one of Ireland’s favourite marques, Opel continues its struggle to make a significant dent in its Merkenich rival, falling even further behind in 2016 with sales now almost half that of Ford – (the Blue Oval up 21% on last year). It seems not even the mighty Jürgen Klopp can work the required miracles here. [I notice they quietly dumped Ms. Schiffer – it’s not you Claudia, it’s most likely us…] Also nipping at Russelsheim’s heels comes Kia with their tiger feet, but while they saw the year out with something of a roar they remain a pale shadow of their Korean stablemates in pure volume terms.

Audi is perhaps the biggest surprise of 2016. Outselling the likes of Dacia, Peugeot and Mazda, their performance really makes a mockery of any pretensions to so called ‘prestige’. Further proof is BMW, directly behind in 11th spot (up 14%) while Mercedes-Benz holds 14th spot, up a mighty 44%. Mind you, with the three pointed star offering a 10% ‘Brexit’ discount this January, questioning the machinery behind Mercedes’ rise wouldn’t be beyond reason.

Looking at the also rans, Alfa Romeo’s six (yes, six) Irish dealers registered total of 43 cars all year, exactly the same as 2015. What were the chances? Coincidentally, I saw my first Giulia yesterday. Who knows, perhaps with a following wind they’ll sell a few, but with no representation outside of the major cities, they’re really going to be up against it.

To see how tough it is to break through, look at Jaguar. Despite posting the biggest percentage sales increase, (a 107% surge on the back of XE and F-Pace), their numbers remain a tiny fraction of the German trioka, even if they’re currently causing Lexus some anxious backwards glances. Nevertheless, the news for JLR here is upbeat, with Land Rover posting a further uplift of 51%. Volvo too saw a 28% rise – they’re currently selling about twice as many cars as Lexus or Jaguar, so while Gothenburg’s new model Blitz might be a bit top-end for many Irish buyers as yet, expect them to play increasingly well to the more moderately well heeled as existing models are replaced. Any betting man would be mad to wager against the Swedes breaking the ‘big three’ chokehold by 2020.

There can’t be much in the way of festivities at Citroën however who continue their steady decline, the non-meshing Chevrons posting the only noteworthy fall in a rising market. With sales down 23% on 2015, the only craic likely to be had are the fissures opening under Ms. Jackson’s feet. Their DS offshoot is now listed separately and to add further fuel the bonfire of PSA’s vanity project, Jan-Dec sales of 13 cars were recorded. Were any sold to actual customers?

Fiat disappointed in 2015, causing their Irish representative, Gerry Clarke to issue us with a polite rebuttal and promises of a better performance come 2016. Last year the FCA volume brand did post a respectable sales rise of 13%. With the Tipo yet to find its feet here, 2017 might see a further uplift, but on balance Fiat’s car range continues to be weighted towards what Irish motorists neither want nor need.

But beyond the appearance of a return to buoyant business in a supposedly ‘post-crash’ Republic, what do the figures tell us? Buying market share is neither new, particularly clever, nor sustainable in the long-term. Despite being beaten to the top spot in 2016, collate VW’s car sales as a group and the picture looks somewhat different. Combined sales -(VW/Audi/Seat/Skoda) of 33,711 versus 22,152 for Kia/Hyundai and 16,115 for Toyota/Lexus see the embattled VW group with a 23% share of the total Irish car market, leaving its rivals in a cloud of noxious particulates.

As they’re fond of saying round these parts: ‘now you’re suckin’ diesel…’

Author: Eóin Doyle

Founder. Editor. Content Provider.

10 thoughts on “And Here Are the Results of the Irish Jury.”

  1. I really enjoyed this analysis. Increasingly, I fear for Citroën and DS Automobiles – the fall off in market share is becoming so acute that new models, when they finally emerge, may be too late to reverse the current momentum. I saw my first new C3 yesterday, and it looks like a baby C4 Cactus – leaving little room for a C3 Cactus, one supposes. So, will the new C4 (if there is one), supplant the existing Cactus as well as the wretched existing C4? I am finding the whole Citroën range increasingly confusing and incoherent.

    Damn, I’d forgotten that I don’t care any more about the once engineering led French marque.

  2. I thought Latin America was the only place to fall prey to Hyundai’s rise – in Brazil, they managed to achieve a “new money” dream status, along with Jeep. The new middle classes around here dream of Tucsons and Renegades. How’s Jeep doing in Ireland?

    1. Richard: Brazil’s road tax also penalises big-engined cars, but the latest FCA’s offerings are either powered by the traditional 2-litre Multijet diesel engine or by 1.8 and 2-litre petrol engines (the former is a stroked version of the 1st-gen BMW Mini engine, whilst the latter is a downsized version of the 2.4-litre Tigershark mill). Thus the two mainstream Jeeps around here (Renegade and Compass) are performing well.

  3. To focus on the 13 DS cars sold. To put that in context, the ROI has has 26 counties. In half of them nobody wanted a DS. More realistically, a few in Dublin, Cork and Kilkenny might have bought one and nobody from anywhere else did.
    I wonder if there are sold more Japanese grey-market cars than DS car in Ireland?

    The Irish are very conservative though. The DS cars are, whether you like them or not, a bit flamboyant. Even if they were a lot better to drive there would be few takers.

  4. Just to follow on from some of the comments here.

    There were 105 Private Imports last year into the RoI market. Some of those might have been grey market Japanese cars, although I’m not sure there is much of a market for them anymore. DS would have killed for those numbers mind you. Richard’s right though. DS is far too frivolous for Irish tastes. They’re suspicious enough of Citroen’s.

    Jeep sold 99 cars last year – up from 93 the year before. Not a stellar performance by anyone’s reckoning. I would have thought the smaller Renegade would have made more of an impact, but perhaps it’s a lack of dealers.

    SV: Fear not, Linda’s got a plan. I don’t know much about it as yet, but she tells me we’re gonna love it. And I of course believe her.

  5. Eóin, interesting story. Y’r top ten list is, from the unitedstatesian perspective, a little strange. Why aren’t, in alphabetical order, Honda, Mazda and Subaru selling more cars in Eire?

    1. Honda have never been a major force in the republic of Ireland, only arriving here in 1985. They came close to being an aspirational upmarket brand during the late 1980’s but lost impetus (along with a lot of their engineering novelty) in the ’90s, as Honda’s focus were aimed further West. Their volumes were up marginally on 2015 (1%) but they were comfortably outsold by Volvo. I don’t think Honda’s offering here is particularly attractive to broader Irish tastes and their current styling is very polarising.
      Mazda sold almost twice as many cars as Honda and also posted a modest rise (2%) on the previous year. Their lack of popularity is more of a mystery, given the excellence of their range, but I do think they are a brand on the way up. Subaru’s car range is incoherent and is heavily penalised by the draconian annual vehicle tax system here. Additionally, Subaru are viewed as quirky and a bit odd. Poison in a heavily conservative market.

      But that’s just my take. Others may have better insight.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.