Mainly Found Wanting – The European CotY prospects

It’s amazing what you’ll find washed up on beaches these days…

Source: European Car of the Year

Is it only for me that the first two months of 2018 have flown by? On Monday it will be time to gather in the rather gloomy hall in the backlands of Palexpo to hear the results of European Car of the Year 2018, along with the grandees of the world’s automotive media, and a few captains of the motor industry feigning insouciance, in the face of the reality that a CotY win still has real sales and profits value.

The Salon des Refusés is often more interesting than short list nominees. We should not be surprised that the Bentley Continental GT, Ferrari 812 Superfast, and McLaren 720S were too rich for the shortlist. No fewer than five new SUVs from various parts of the VAG Reich went by the board, and Opel’s cup of woe continues to overflow, with the Insignia, Crossland X, and Grandland  X failing to make the final list. They’re having a rotten year.

My personal regrets are the absence of the Alpine A110, Suzuzi Ignis, and Volvo XC60, the last being more ‘rounded’ in its capabilities than XC40 which made it to the final seven.

Let’s remind ourselves of the final seven:

Source: European Car of the Year

Alfa Romeo Stelvio.  Does it bring anything new to the SUV party? The Giulia did well, but not well enough in last year’s vote. I’d expect a reasonable showing.

Source: European Car of the Year

Audi A8.  Doesn’t quite match the BMW G30 5 Series for utter bankruptcy on the stylistic progression front, but it comes close. Does technological density make a good car? This one looks like a dead end on a rapidly changing street map.

Source: European Car of the Year

BMW 5 Series.  If there’s light, it’s hidden under a bushel. That said, a car I could happily live with.

Source: European Car of the Year

Citroën C3 Aircross.  PSA do these things well and this is a particularly neat example.

Source: European Car of the Year

Kia Stinger.  The dark horse. Fighting its way into a demanding and diminishing sector. To paraphrase Borges, will it be yet another bald man fighting over that comb?

Source: European Car of the Year

Seat Ibiza.  Interesting that this, rather than the Polo, went forward to the finalists. As good a supermini as one could wish for, which was also true of the outgoing Polo which won CotY in 2010.

Source: European Car of the Year

Volvo XC40.  Like Alfa, Volvo have done well, but not quite well enough, in recent CotY finals. A win for the XC40 would be just reward for the impressive progress the company have made under Geely ownership.

Source: European Car of the Year

Finally, in the latest Autocropley, Matt Prior, the august publication’s Road Test Editor reports that he is ‘being brave’ with his CotY vote. He explains himself well, without giving away his choice, but I deplore the devaluation of the concept of ‘bravery’, which has gone the way of ‘hero’, an epithet now wasted on football players or drug-addled competitive bicycle riders.

6 thoughts on “Mainly Found Wanting – The European CotY prospects”

  1. It ought to be the Ibiza, but might be the Volvo even though it’s the wrong model. The C3 could do it, and I like the way it avoids the near-ubiquitous rhomboid air scoops.

    It won’t be niche stuff like Stinger or Stelvio — although if I were a Lottery winner the latter would be all I’d need.

  2. I like and trust Matt Prior, though cannot guess at the implications of his ‘bravery’. There aren’t really any brave picks on that short list.

    COTY has long been criticised for picking the safest option, but in this case I also think the SEAT Ibiza represents the best choice. Progress never quite goes the way you think it will, but this model is at the cutting edge of what is available to the mass market these days.

    1. It appears that Matt Prior’s bravery only went as far as voting for BMW’s torpid looking 5-er. I’m presuming that the choice itself was considered brave, rather than the car in question.

      In my view, the closest to a brave choice Mr. Prior could have made was to vote maximum points for the Stinger, given that (to my knowledge) no Korean car has ever won ECotY.

  3. I’m now on the ground in Geneva. So far I’ve only spoken to Autocropley and a Bauer personage. The view from the latter is that CotY could go any way. I’m more and more thinking it will be Volvo’s turn, just gut feeling.

  4. It’s the Volvo. Which doesn’t take us any further forward at all.

    If they’d launched it with a hybrid version, I could have been persuaded.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.