All Wrapped Up the Same

ECOTY 2019 is soon to be upon us. Who will learn to accept their reward this coming March?

(c) carscoops

As November slips silently from our grasp, and the season of good cheer has not yet fully broken upon us, we find ourselves at Driven to Write already looking ahead to March. But neither time, news agendas nor indeed my senior editor are known for qualities of patience or mercy, meaning I’m bound at least occasionally to report on the stories (as they say), that matter. The shortlist for the 2019 European Car of the Year award was officially announced this week, so let us take this opportunity to consider the seven finalists’ chances of tearful acceptance at Geneva in the Spring.

The international COTY jury, consisting of 60 representatives from the countries of Austria, Belgium, Czech Republic, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Luxembourg, Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Russia, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Turkey, and the United Kingdom, having cast their first vote, saw the initial 38 potential nominees whittled down to the seven finalists now vying for Car of the Year 2019 trophy.

(c) ECotY

As you will no doubt recall, this year’s award was something of a landslide for Volvo’s XC40 crossover, amassing 325 points and 24 individual top votes ahead of the Seat Ibiza (242 points) and the BMW 5-series (226 points) among the seven finalists. “Quality, looks, ruggedness and, of course, safety are among the aspects appreciated by Jury members for this SUV of surely high acceptance,” ECOTY said of the Tonka-Swede. And with Global sales of 58,111* in the year to October, they can scarcely churn them out fast enough at Ghent.

(c) Robertas Parazitas

The first and perhaps most surprising finalist is Renault-owned Alpine, with the pert and critically acclaimed A110. Overt sports machines such as this have not typically fared well at ECOTY, so for Alpine to take home the trophy would be unprecedented. But stranger things have happened and these are indeed, interesting times.

(c) Citroen

Second of France’s three finalists and the first of PSA’s two entrants is Citroën’s C5 Aircross CUV. Currently the largest car model to bear the double chevron, much is made of the Citroën’s emphasis on passenger comfort and value. And while it’s likely the C5 will score well, with the home jury at least, the fact that Peugeot’s architecturally related 3008 took the honours two years ago is surely likely to militate against it.

(c) Autocar

The first of three mainstream C-sector hatchbacks in contention is Ford’s current Focus model. Bigger, more tech-laden and anodyne in appearance than any car to bear the Focus nameplate since its inception 20 years ago, the mid-sized Ford has nevertheless been critically well received, and stands a strong chance of a top-three finish, maybe even the top spot. Which would undoubtedly go down well at Köln-Merkenich.

(c) Wired

Having rejected its less than impressive junior CUV sibling, the sole UK-developed vehicle to make this year’s shortlist is JLR’s Jaguar’s I-Pace. Electric vehicles have won here in the past – Nissan’s Leaf taking the gong in 2011, (not to mention Tesla’s Model S third position in 2014) so there is a precedent. If the jurors can ignore the Jaguar’s withering price-tag, it could conceivably be favourite to take the win.

(c) Auto-Didakt

Kia’s Ceed has not only lost its once-defining apostrophe, but also a good deal of styling distinctiveness in its second generation. Nevertheless, it remains a sober-suited, finely honed consumer durable of broad ability and strong appeal, which will ensure it scores highly. What it lacks is an indefinable sparkle, but that quality (or indeed its lack) has not necessarily troubled the ECOTY jury in the past.

(c) Auto-Didakt

Coming immediately after the Ceed could prove confusing for the jurors, such are the physical resemblances between the Korean contender and Sindelfingen’s latest C-segment entrant. Expected to score highly on its ‘Flash Gorden’ cabin ambience and up to the minute tech, the Mercedes A-Class is otherwise as normative a choice as the Ford or Kia that precede it. A top three position seems likely, but a win would surely be something of a travesty.

(c) ANE

The final contender is Peugeot’s 508, the latest in what is billed as a return to form from the Lion of Belfort. Strong on visual appeal, however Socheaux’s current flagship appears to have left some critics wanting on more substantive matters. There is likely to be a groundswell of support for this sole representative of a traditional, now fading format, but the top spot nevertheless seems fanciful.

And there you have it. Seven finalists, but only one in their midst with a winning hand. The final vote will take place in March, with each juror apportioning 25 points amongst their selected five nominees. The car of the year will be revealed on the eve of the Geneva Motorshow on March 4th 2019.

Driven to Write will as ever, do our utmost to bring you the result live from the Palexpo – assuming we get our metaphorical ducks in a row. Meanwhile, like the rest of us, the very least you can do is speculate.

*Volvo Cars

Author: Eóin Doyle

Co-Founder. Editor. Content Provider.

7 thoughts on “All Wrapped Up the Same”

  1. For purely selfish reasons I hope the Peugeot 508 takes top spot. Any firm that can go from making salt and pepper mills to this in two hundred or so years deserves a medal.
    But I’m more taken with the Teardrop Explodes reference – All hail Julian Cope!

  2. Potential for a genuinely interesting and deserving COTY here. But sadly I doubt the Alpine or i-Pace will win.

  3. Best chances for the Alpine and the Jaguar, because PSA has som car of the last years, the Focus and the Ceed are no milestones or will at least be able to steal customers from other companies and because the A-class is wrong here. Without any doubt.

    My COTY 2019 is the Suzuki Jimny.

  4. I’d like the 508 to win (stylish, good value), or the I-Pace (a big step forward for Jaguar). However, the Focus is meant to be brilliant to drive and they last won in 2007, so my money would be on them.

    Here’s the list of all 38 contenders. I must say that I’d not registered the Hyundai Nexo. Shame about the Jimny, too.

    1. Thanks for the interesting list.
      6 Audis and no one has reached the final – a good choice
      All new BMWs are ugly and worth to be not elected
      The picture of the old Jimny shows how big the improvement of the new one is
      I never heard of this Hyundai too – a fuel cell car is a senseless car in my eyes
      The new Lexus cars were unknown for me – taking a look at their german website is telling me, that they are offering 13 different cars – without any hope of having a model that is lifting the small sales.

  5. The one truism about annual awards of any kind is they’re handed out regardless of whether any contender is actually any good or not. Must feed the maw of corporatism and butter up the egos of the chosen “judges”. I learned this about 1962 at the age of 14.

  6. Markus: poor old Lexus. What went wrong? They have some interesting vehicles most of which I don´t know the name of (CT anyone) , such as some coupes (LC and RC) and the evergreen LS saloon. I don´t think they sell well in Denmark at all. I seem them more in Ireland than around here. One thing working against them is the Waku-Doki. I happen to like it, unusually for me, and believe Lexus screw their cars together with unusual determination. The affuent public seem not to be moved by this, which is a bit unfair.

    The last Jimny is a cracker, in my view. The styling was able to last 20 years and still looked relevant in its last year. Further critiques of the Jimny will be treated with unflinching ruthlessness.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: